Resurrection Stories: Overcoming Obstacles

John 21:15-19
May 15, 2011




When they had finished breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, “Simon son of John, do you love me more than these?” He said to him, “Yes, Lord; you know that I love you.” Jesus said to him, “Feed my lambs.” A second time he said to him, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” He said to him, “Yes, Lord; you know that I love you.” Jesus said to him, “Tend my sheep.” He said to him the third time, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” Peter felt hurt because he said to him the third time, “Do you love me?” And he said to him, “Lord, you know everything; you know that I love you.” Jesus said to him, “Feed my sheep. Very truly, I tell you, when you were younger, you used to fasten your own belt and to go wherever you wished. But when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will fasten a belt around you and take you where you do not wish to go.” (He said this to indicate the kind of death by which he would glorify God.) After this he said to him, “Follow me.”

I want you to imagine that you are founding an entrepreneurial venture, and that you are looking for an organizing president. What qualities do you look for? Do you look for experience? Do you look for evidence of commitment? Do you try to assess the person’s potential loyalty to you? Do you look for an understanding of your venture’s mission? Do you look for honesty? What are the key factors you look for?

If these are the factors we look for in a founding president, then there can be only one conclusion about Jesus’ efforts to hire a founding president of his entrepreneurial venture, the Christian Church: Jesus was a lousy entrepreneur.

I want you to think about who he chose as his organizing president. He chose Peter, and the fact is that this was a man who had no entrepreneurial experience. He had been a fisherman with little education or experience in organizing anything. He had a fairly shallow understanding of Jesus’ mission. Remember, he constantly misunderstood Jesus’ work. How often did Jesus have to say to him, “Get behind me Satan,” or correct Peter’s misperceptions, or point out Peter’s shortcomings? Peter also had a lack of commitment when times got tough, as well as a lack of loyalty. Think about how Peter reacted once Jesus was arrested. Three times people came up to him and said, “Hey, weren’t you one of the people following that guy Jesus?” And three times Peter said, “Naw, man, you got me confused with someone else. I didn’t know him.” Jesus sure knows how to pick ‘em.

Actually, Jesus did know how to pick them. Despite all the shortcomings of his founding president, Peter did a good enough job that the results speak for themselves. Look at their entrepreneurial venture today. It’s the most successful of all time. The church has grown by about 3,000,000,000% (if you take into consideration all present and past Christians in the world), it has lasted for 2000 years, it has cornered over 1/3rd of today’s world religion market, and it’s operations book, the Bible, has been the #1 selling book for 1500 years. That’s a pretty good entrepreneurial venture.

A lot of the success of the venture has to do with picking Peter as it’s founding president, and it shows the values Jesus looks for in us, as well as in Peter. For Jesus, it’s not about how perfect we are. It’s about how willing we are to change, grow, and to be unsinkable in the process. Our passage for this morning shows all this.

Jesus, who is appearing to them after his resurrection, has gathered the disciples by the lakeshore to teach them. He focuses in on Peter, asking him three times, “Do you love me?” Each time Peter gets more distressed at the question. “Why would Jesus keep asking him?” he thinks. “Doesn’t he know how much I love him?” What he doesn’t pick up is that Jesus asks the question for each time that Peter had previously denied him. Jesus is ramming home a point: “You, Peter, denied me three times when it mattered most, so I want to hear from you that you love me. I have something big for you, and I want to make sure that you are ready for it. I want to see if you’ve changed, if you’re ready for something very hard—a life lived in service to me.” In fact, at the end Jesus tells Peter that he is going to suffer for his service, saying that he will be led in shackles to where he doesn’t want to go. What Jesus says is true. Years later Peter was led in shackles to Rome, where he was crucified upside-down.

What this story tells us is that despite what we may think, God doesn’t look for us to be perfect. Instead, God looks for us to be like water. What does that mean? Think about how water responds to obstacles it hits as it comes down a mountain. It will either overcome the obstacle, find a way around it, or eventually erode it. Water can’t be stopped. God looks for us to be like water. It’s not a matter of where we come from. It’s a matter of how we face difficulties, struggles, and obstacles. Are we willing to always work to overcome them, with God’s help? Are we willing to get up when we are knocked down, look for hope when we are in despair, find God’s way when things look blocked? You see, with God, we aren’t defined by our flaws, failures, or sins, but by how we respond to them. Do we let them defeat us, or do we look to God to overcome them. Let me show you what I mean.

If you travel to the business district of New Orleans, you can find a statue of a woman named Margaret that was erected in 1888. It’s an odd statue, not like most statues you find in a city. Most statues in a city are of military, political, or financial men posed dramatically, showing their great deeds. This statue of Margaret is different. It has Margaret, an older, heavy-set woman in a crocheted sweater, hair in a bun, sitting on a chair with her arm around a small child standing next to her. The inscription on the base simply says, “Margaret.”

The statue is of Margaret Haughery, a woman who died in New Orleans in 1882. By the time she died, she had made a huge impact on the city. No one would have expected her to be remembered in marble when she was born in Ireland in 1814. At age six she migrated to America with her parents, settling in Maryland. Two years later, both parents died of influenza, leaving her an orphan. After a time in an orphanage, a Welsh couple adopted her. At age twenty-one she married and moved to New Orleans with her new husband. About a year or two later, both her husband and her infant child died of illness, leaving Margaret in poverty.

Eventually, she got a job washing and ironing clothes in a Catholic orphanage. It was there that she sensed her calling. One day she went to the head nun and committed her life to helping the orphanage financially. Saving as much as she could, she donated much of her salary back to the orphanage. With what she had saved she managed to purchase two cows and a small, wooden pushcart. She would rise very early in the morning and deliver milk to wealthy people and restaurants, often begging for leftover food so that she could give that to the orphans.

As her side business grew, she purchased more cows and hired people to deliver the milk. Out of her revenues she kept little for herself. She saved much of it, and gave much of the rest to the orphanage. As her business increased, she eventually sold it, and with the proceeds, both donated huge sums to the orphanage, helping them get completely out of debt. Then she bought a bakery. As the bakery business took off, she gave more money not only to the Catholic orphanage she had worked in years before, but also to Protestant and Jewish orphanages.

When she died in 1882, she left $30,000 to be shared with orphanages all over the city. By my best guess, that would be over $1 million in today’s dollars. All from a woman who could barely read or write, but who was willing to sacrifice herself for the benefit of others.

You’ve heard that God helps those who help themselves? That’s not quite true. What is true is that God helps those who look to God. Embedded in the Christian faith is a simple idea, which is that nothing can keep us down if we put our faith in God. It’s not about how good, or perfect, or strong we are. It’s about being like Peter. We might fail and falter, but if our faith is in God, we can overcome anything to do wonderful things.

Amen.

Resurrection Stories: Discovering Deeper Truths



Luke 24:13-35
May 8, 2011

Now on that same day two of them were going to a village called Emmaus, about seven miles from Jerusalem, and talking with each other about all these things that had happened. While they were talking and discussing, Jesus himself came near and went with them, but their eyes were kept from recognizing him. And he said to them, “What are you discussing with each other while you walk along?” They stood still, looking sad. Then one of them, whose name was Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who does not know the things that have taken place there in these days?” He asked them, “What things?” They replied, “The things about Jesus of Nazareth, who was a prophet mighty in deed and word before God and all the people, and how our chief priests and leaders handed him over to be condemned to death and crucified him. But we had hoped that he was the one to redeem Israel. Yes, and besides all this, it is now the third day since these things took place. Moreover, some women of our group astounded us. They were at the tomb early this morning, and when they did not find his body there, they came back and told us that they had indeed seen a vision of angels who said that he was alive. Some of those who were with us went to the tomb and found it just as the women had said; but they did not see him.” Then he said to them, “Oh, how foolish you are, and how slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have declared! Was it not necessary that the Messiah should suffer these things and then enter into his glory?” Then beginning with Moses and all the prophets, he interpreted to them the things about himself in all the scriptures. As they came near the village to which they were going, he walked ahead as if he were going on. But they urged him strongly, saying, “Stay with us, because it is almost evening and the day is now nearly over.” So he went in to stay with them. When he was at the table with them, he took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them. Then their eyes were opened, and they recognized him; and he vanished from their sight. They said to each other, “Were not our hearts burning within us while he was talking to us on the road, while he was opening the scriptures to us?” That same hour they got up and returned to Jerusalem; and they found the eleven and their companions gathered together. They were saying, “The Lord has risen indeed, and he has appeared to Simon!” Then they told what had happened on the road, and how he had been made known to them in the breaking of the bread.


Those of you who have been in this church or around me for a while know that among my favorite authors is C. S. Lewis. And among Lewis’ books, one of my favorites is The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. From the moment I read it as a 12 year-old, it spoke to me about things that I knew I would never completely understand. The whole Chronicles of Narnia series, which includes this book, does that. That first book, The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, speaks to truths about Christ’s death and resurrection that is hard to grasp fully with our conscious minds.

I especially love one scene in the book that speaks of this deeper truth. The scene is central to the book. One of the four human siblings, Edmund, has betrayed his brother and sisters to the White Witch, who wants to kill all of them. There is a prophecy that when two human boys and two human girls appear in Narnia (a land of talking animals who have been under the witch’s power for 100 years), her reign will be over. Edmund betrays them, and the White Witch invokes a law of Narnia, which is that if one human betrays another to her, she has the right to sacrifice the betrayer.

Aslan, who is a great lion, and literally is Jesus in Narnia (he tells the children in another book that they know him by that name in their world), offers himself as a sacrifice. The White Witch knew that Aslan’s love would lead him to sacrifice himself, and she relishes it. She knows that with Aslan dead, she will be free to reign forever.

Appearing before the witch and her evil creatures, Aslan is led onto a primeval stone table, with ancient, long-forgotten writing on it. He is mocked as he is bound, shaved, and laughed at. Lying on this altar, Aslan looks out in grief and pain. Two of the children, Susan and Lucy, watch from their hiding place. After much abuse, Aslan is killed by the witch. All the evil creatures laugh and dance in joy over his broken body. Finally, they leave to attack the army of Narnians, led by Susan’s and Lucy’s brotehr, Peter.

Once the evil creatures have crawled and slithered away, Susan and Lucy come over to Aslan and sob over his lifeless body. They are crushed. All hope is gone. After a while, they walk away. Suddenly they hear a loud CRACK! They look over and Aslan’s body is gone. They wonder who has taken it. Then, from the side, they see a looming figure. It’s Aslan. And he’s alive. They can’t believe it. Aslan roars, and then comes down to them, and they all roll in the grass, playing and laughing.

As they settle down and catch their breaths, the children ask Aslan how he could be alive. He says to them that the White Witch knew the laws of Narnia, but not the deeper magic of his Father. If she had only been able to read the writing on the stone table, she would have known that when someone willingly sacrifices himself for another’s sin, then that sin is forgiven and life is restored. He says that there are deeper truths to the realm of Narnia than the White Witch can ever understand.

That scene speaks so much about what I would call “God-truths.” These are truths about God that go beyond our ability to understand. They aren’t just truths that take time to learn, but they are truths that we can’t understand no matter how hard we try to figure them out. We can only experience them. The truth is that there is so much about how God acts in life that we don’t understand, and because we don’t understand, we shut ourselves off to God. We are a people who think that for anything to be true, we have to be able to understand it cognitively. But so much of life, the universe, and God lay beyond our ability to comprehend. Our passage is a perfect example of this truth.

Jesus meets two disciples, two men who had known Jesus intimately. They had been taught all of his teachings, but that’s not the same as them understanding his teachings. They knew all the right things, but they didn’t understand. They talk to Jesus as they walk, but they don’t recognize him. Jesus explains to them everything that had happened and, but because the resurrected Jesus makes no sense to them, they fail to recognize him. I’m sure Jesus was doing something to fog their abilities, but whatever he did was aided by the fact that they already have an understanding about how the world works, and the possibility of a resurrected Jesus made no sense. They had heard that some had seen him, but they were rational, logical men. For them, resurrection wasn’t possible.

It wasn’t until Jesus broke the bread and shared the wine at dinner that they recognized him, and recognized that they had just experienced a deeper truth. They still didn’t understand, but they had discovered Gods “deeper magic.”

For those of you who have been in this church for a long time, you know that I’m fascinated by stories, like this one, of God that reveal deeper truths. And I’m not just talking about deeper truths that we can figure out. I love stories that go beyond our cognitive understanding, that push the boundaries of what we can conceive of in our heads. I love stories about what God is doing in this world that push aside the known laws of this world.

I tell these kinds of stories in my sermons, I write about them in my books (and I’ve been criticized in book reviews for that fact), I talk about them in personal conversations, and I push books that share and teach these kinds of stories. The reason I’m so fascinated with these kinds of stories is that I truly believe that just as there is a deeper magic than the White Witch understood with Aslan, there are deeper truths about God than we understand, and that our doctrine and dogmas fail to capture. These are truths that we can’t necessarily explain. Instead, we experience them.

Let me close by sharing one of these kinds of stories. Over the past three months, our men’s group has been reading and discussing a fascinating book that you’ve heard me talk about in the past. The book is Father Arseny: Priest, Prisoner, and Spiritual Guide. It’s a book written by people who had come to know this amazing, Russian Orthodox priest during his lifetime. He lived during the Soviet period of Russia’s history, spending 27 years living in a Siberian gulag during Joseph Stalin’s savage reign. This was a time in which religion was forbidden, and people who practiced their faith could be imprisoned or killed. Father Arseny managed to live a life of deep faith during his brutal and torturous imprisonment, and he influenced thousands—both those in the camp with him, and those he met before and afterwards.

At the end of the book there is a story about one of his spiritual children, a woman he acted as spiritual guide to. Father Arseny had written a series of letters to many of the faithful he knew who were struggling under the oppressive, atheistic Communism of the Soviet Union. These were letters of spiritual encouragement, but they were dangerous. If found by the KGB, they would have implicated many as being Christians, and as worshiping together in secret.

A woman named Natasha took the letters from Father Arseny, and traveled to a town where she gave them to another woman named Alexandra. Knowing that Alexandra was frightened to take the letters and deliver them, she said to Alexandra the same words that Father Arseny had said to her: “God will protect you. He will be with you. Do not be afraid of anything. All will be well!”

As Alexandra set off to deliver the letters, she immediately felt as though someone was following her. She could hear footsteps about 50 to 70 yards behind her. Her heart raced. She didn’t know what to do. If she was caught,… well, she didn’t want to think of what might happen. Her pace quickened as she tried to elude her tail. She knew it was a KGB agent. She wondered if she should throw away the letters and run, but she knew that would make things worse. The KGB would get the letters, and all would be implicated, including Father Arseny.

So she slowed down and began to pray. She prayed to the virgin Mary, asking Mary to bring God’s protection (in the Orthodox tradition, many pray to Mary, or “Mother of God” as they call her). As she prayed, she soon noticed a second set of footsteps behind her. She didn’t feel fear at the sound of those footsteps. She felt oddly calm. Those footsteps came closer. As she turned a corner, a woman caught up with her. She was dressed exactly like her. She was the same age, had the same purse on her shoulder and kerchief on her head. She walked next to Alexandra, but said nothing. Her faced looked familiar, and had an amazing glow to it, but she really couldn’t make out the features.

Reaching a street corner, Alexandra’s companion turned to her and sternly said, “Stop here and stand. I will keep walking.” Standing completely still, the KGB agent—an angry-looking woman in her 30s—caught up to her, looked her up and down, and hurried on to catch the other woman. Alexandra was free! Within a few hours, Alexandra had delivered all the letters.

A year later Alexandra was arrested as a suspect. At the interrogation she was asked repeatedly what had happened to her companion on that day. Alexandra insisted that she had done nothing wrong. They eventually brought in her KGB tail, who said, “There I am walking, comrade Lieutenant, following her, she turns corners to lose me. But I follow her… When I came to the corner of Kazakov Street, somebody was standing, and another woman looking exactly like the first one walked away. They were identical, dressed the same way, same kerchiefs, same boots, same coat, same purse, same gait, same turn of the head. I followed them, but I couldn’t figure out which one I had been following from the beginning and which one appeared on that street corner. I followed the one who was walking away. I walked behind her for some ten minutes when she suddenly disappeared into thin air. I swear I am telling you the truth—she simply disappeared. Ask this woman, let her tell you what she did. It was just like a disappearing act in a circus.”

Alexandra told them that she didn’t know who the woman was, and in act of brazen spiritual boldness said, “I did not hide anywhere, I did not disappear. The Mother of God saved me. I had been walking and praying to her the whole time.” The interrogator laughed. They had to punish her some way, so Alexandra was sentenced to live in a small town outside of Moscow. For those times this was considered an extremely light punishment.

So, who was that with Alexandra? Mary? An angel? Who knows? What I do know is that to be a Christian means to be open to truths, and experiences based on those truths, that go beyond our understanding. It means being open to Alexandra’s experience. In fact, we Christians depend upon these experiences because we know that there is more to life than what we know, and what we think we know. We may not have the same kind of experience as Alexandra, but that doesn’t mean we can’t experience deeper truths.

We may advance in knowledge and sophistication in any age, but really understanding the truths of God isn’t about gaining new information. It’s about transformation. It’s about being open to truths that lay beyond laws, knowledge, and our convictions about how the world, universe, and God work. To become open to these kinds of experiential truths means to be open to God’s transforming and mysterious truths.

The question for you is simple: Are you open to this kind of mysterious transformation?

Amen.

Resurrection Stories: Overcoming Doubt




John 20:19-31
May 1, 2011

When it was evening on that day, the first day of the week, and the doors of the house where the disciples had met were locked for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you.” After he said this, he showed them his hands and his side. Then the disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord. Jesus said to them again, “Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, so I send you.” When he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” But Thomas (who was called the Twin), one of the twelve, was not with them when Jesus came. So the other disciples told him, “We have seen the Lord.” But he said to them, “Unless I see the mark of the nails in his hands, and put my finger in the mark of the nails and my hand in his side, I will not believe.”
A week later his disciples were again in the house, and Thomas was with them. Although the doors were shut, Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you.” Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here and see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it in my side. Do not doubt but believe.” Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe.” Now Jesus did many other signs in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book. But these are written so that you may come to believe that Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God, and that through believing you may have life in his name.


I don’t know if you realize this, but there is a basic truth to growing as a Christian. It’s a paradoxical truth because it seems to stray from what many of us have learned growing up. The basic truth is this: if you don’t have doubts, and you don’t have questions, you don’t really have faith. Let me repeat what I just said: if you don’t have doubts, and you don’t have questions, you don’t really have faith.

I know,… I know,… we’ve all grown up learning that we have to have a blind faith. In fact, that idea of having a blind faith comes out of this passage, where Jesus says, “Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe.” I don’t think Jesus is saying that being like Thomas and having doubts is wrong, while having a blind faith is right. Jesus has already blessed Thomas, and he’s saying that those who don’t have doubts also are blessed. He’s blessing everyone who has faith, no matter what course their faith has taken. Still, my experience tells me that the people who really develop the deepest faith do so after having overcome doubt and questioning.

I’ve learned how important doubting and questioning to growing faith both on a personal level and through my studies over the years. I’m a person who’s struggled with doubts and questions for much of my adolescent and adult life. You may or may not know this, but I never went to seminary to become a pastor. I went to get answers. The call to be a pastor came as a surprise to me, and only in my last year of seminary. My focus in going to seminary was to help my counseling career. I went to seminary to get answers to my spiritual and theological questions that would help me personally, and help me in my work with people struggling spiritually in their everyday lives. I had questions and doubts.

Even after I became a pastor, I still had questions about everything—about Jesus, God, the Christian life, and much more. I ended up working on my Ph.D., not because it would help my career, but because I wanted to dig deeper for answers. And all along the way I discovered that the more questions I got answered, the more new questions I had. Every answer opened up the door to new questions. Even today I outread most people I know because I have so many questions about what it means to be human, how the human brain works, how organizations work and why, what God is doing in the world, how to understand politics, how to understand history, and much more.

I’ve always been a person plagues with questions and doubts. Those doubts caused me to walk away from the church in my teens because I wasn’t sure the church could provide answers. I’m not alone in this. I’ve been surprised at how many other pastors walked away from the church as teens. I had lunch this past week with a Roman Catholic priest who told me that he had walked away from the church as a teen, and that he had been a drummer in a heavy-metal rock band before coming back to the church and going to seminary. Connie Frierson, who will be ordained as associate pastor in the next few months here at Calvin Church, has a similar history. She walked away from the church, and then ended up joining here and going to seminary, all to find answers to her doubts and questions.

All of us pastors who walked away from the church are in good company biblically because we are just like Thomas. I know that in the Presbyterian tradition we don’t have saints. Well, actually, we do. Everyone of faith is considered a saint. What we don’t have is set-aside or patron saints. If we did, though, Thomas could very well be the patron saint of the Presbyterian Church because we are a church that allows doubts and questions. We don’t demand blind faith. We invite a learned faith. We invite people to struggle with their questions. Why Thomas? Because he doubted, and it led him to the greatest commitment of any of the apostles.

You probably don’t know much about the fate of all the apostles (other than Peter and Paul) after Jesus ascended, but they have interesting histories. And Thomas’ history is as interesting as it gets. We don’t know how accurate this history is, since it was not written down till years after Thomas died, but here’s his story. Thomas was the most doubting, but he ended up being the most faithful. Christ called him to perhaps the most difficult ministry of any of the apostles.

After the Day of Pentecost, the apostles gathered together and cast lots to decide who would go where to spread the Gospel. Andrew was sent to the region that is now Armenia. Peter would stay in Jerusalem (and eventually move to Damascus and then Antioch). Later, Paul would go to what is now Turkey and Greece. Others were sent elsewhere. To Thomas fell the duty of spreading the Gospel in India, a place Thomas did not want to go to. Thomas complained: “I don’t want to go. I’m not healthy enough. I don’t speak the languages. It’s too dangerous. I’m the wrong person. I’m not going.” His refusal changed one day when he met Jesus in the marketplace. The tradition says that Jesus told him that he wanted him to go to India. Again, Thomas complained. So Jesus approached a traveling merchant in the marketplace named Abbanes and offered to sell Thomas to him as a slave. He told Abbanes that Thomas had carpentry skills, which he needed. The price was agreed upon, and Abbanes approached Thomas and said, “Is that your master over there?” pointing to Jesus. When Thomas said yes, Abbanes, said, “He has just sold you to me. You are now my servant.”

Thomas went with Abbanes first to what is modern-day Pakistan, settling in the Indus River valley. It was one of the great cradles of civilization, along with the Nile, the Tigris and Euphrates, the Ganges, and the Yangtze. It was there that Thomas eventually was sold to and worked in the palace of the king, Gundaphorus. Thomas shared the Gospel with him, and after a number of years received his freedom and preached throughout India. It was a difficult mission because many parts of India were ungoverned and dangerous. Over the course of twenty years, Thomas faithfully traveled throughout India, spreading the Gospel. He eventually settled near Madras, where he was tortured with red-hot plates because of what he was preaching, and then was killed by being run through with a spear. The church started by Thomas, the Mar-Thoma Orthodox Church, which has about 2.5 million members world-wide, still exists in many parts of India.

Thomas, even though he doubted, balked, and complained, also served with tremendous courage in places that were more dangerous than any other in which the other apostles served. Thomas is my hero because he points the way to being an “authentic” Christian. He is the model for the struggling Christian who has doubts and questions, but never lets them get in the way of coming to God. In Thomas the questions led him to get closer to God, and to do more in service to God than ever anticipated.

I believe that one of the problems of our culture today is that our doubts are compounded with laziness. We have a lot of people who say that they yearn to find God in their lives, but then do nothing about it. For example, so many people in our culture today say, “I’m spiritual but not religious.” That, to me, is a lazy person’s answer. When they say, “I get more out of going into the woods than in church,” or “I get more doing yoga than in being in church,” I hear people saying, “I’m too lazy to actually work on my spirituality. So I’m going to do what’s easy.” Like them, I love going out into the woods, and I do find God there. I also do yoga most mornings as part of my prayer ritual. I’m one of the few 52 year-old men who can actually place my palms on the floor while standing with straight legs. But if that’s the extent of your spirituality, it’s lazy. It’s doing nothing. It’s like saying that I’m a true athlete, but I find athletic success best by playing catch in my back yard. Or it’s like saying that I’m wonderful chef, and my best dish is boiling pasta. To be an athlete you have to work at your sport. To be a great chef you have to actually work at cooking. To be truly spiritual, you have to actually work on your spirituality, and without any kind of religious practice, how are you working on it?

So many people have questions and doubts, and it leads them to do little or nothing. Evangelical Churches really understand how spiritually lazy many people are, in a way that many of us in our Mainline churches don’t. They actually tailor their churches to people who are immature spiritually, either because they never grew up in church, or because they walked away after confirmation. So they do things to make religion easier. For example, in most of those large, evangelical churches, do you know what term they give their worship services? They don’t call them “contemporary.” They call them “seeker” services. They are trying to create services for people who are spiritually curious, but are afraid of deeper spiritual, theological answers. They create them for those who are just “seeking,” but haven’t gone very deep. They are targeting the most spiritually immature, which I believe is a good thing. We’re not set up for that, though. We’re set up not as a church for seekers, but as a church for “deepers”—for people who want to go deeper into Christian faith and spirituality.

If you read the writings of pastors and others out of the evangelical, mega-church movement, they are written for people with little spiritual or religious background. They tend to write to people at an 8th or 9th grade level. How do I know this? It all has to do with the SMOG test. I don’t mean an environmental air-pollution test. The SMOG (SMOG stands for “standard measure of gobbledygook) test is a reading test that Bruce Smith made me aware of. Back in 1968 an educational researcher named G Harry McLaughlin came up with a formula to determine what grade level a person was writing at. It was a helpful test in guiding writers to write at an age-appropriate level. The test is fairly simple. You take 30 lines of any book. You then count the number of words that have more than two syllables. You then take the square root of that number (or the square root of the squared number closest to that number) and add 3.

Most of what I write is written at a 12th-grade or college level, according to the SMOG test. When you read books coming out of the evangelical world, they tend to be written at about an 8th or 9th grade level with large print and lots of white space. My saying this is not my saying that their writings are bad or wrong. There are many good books that I have read that are written at this level. One reason that Rick Warren’s Purpose-Driven Life was so popular is that it was written at an 8th grade level. If you want to see why I say that, apply the SMOG test to it. I think his book is a very good book, but it is written for people who are at an 8th or 9th grade religious level. It is written for people who either don’t have many questions, or who have been somewhat lazy spiritually and want simpler, easier answers. Warren’s book is good, but there are so many more that are truly exceptional, but reading them requires a willingness to use our questioning and doubts to dig deeper.

In the Presbyterian Church (USA) and at Calvin Presbyterian Church, we allow people to doubt and question, and we invite people to grow deeper. We are not a tradition or a church that expects blind faith. We expect a questioning faith. I really believe that one of the gifts of the Presbyerian tradition is that we both encourage and expect people to move beyond a 9th grade religious level. We encourage and expect people to have questions and doubts, and we try to create classes and groups that move people deeper.

You see this whole emphasis on questions, doubts, education, and growing emphasized throughout our church and the whole Presbyterian tradition. For instance, if you look at our robes, they’re different from the ones Lutherans, Episcopalians, and Roman Catholic pastors and priests wear. Think about where else you’ve seen people in our culture with these kinds of robes. You see them in universities and colleges. Professors wear them at graduation. Our robes are academic robes, and it emphasizes that we pastors are primarily to be teachers. It’s also for this reason in the Presbyterian Church that so many of our pastors have doctorates. We get them because we not only believe that education is important, but because so many of us pastors have our doubts and questions, and we are always working to get answers, which of course leads us to new questions. We Presbyterian pastors are questioners leading others to both question and to find answers.

Too many Christians today come armed with strong opinions, but with little study. They have a little knowledge, and they use it to criticize and judge people, while they stay safely in their own little ignorant and arrogant bubbles. But we’re different. We’re a people called to recognize that there is so much that we don’t know, and that we need to humbly strive for greater learning. This is what Thomas has taught us. He’s taught us that our doubts and questions can lead to an even greater faith.

From Thomas we also get an important question that we need to answer if we’re going to grow in faith: how committed are we to really growing spiritually, to forging ahead for answers to questions, and to learning what God has to teach?

Amen.

Resurrection Stories: MIracles Rising

John 20:1-18
April 24, 2011

Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, Mary Magdalene came to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the tomb. So she ran and went to Simon Peter and the other disciple, the one whom Jesus loved, and said to them, “They have taken the Lord out of the tomb, and we do not know where they have laid him.” Then Peter and the other disciple set out and went toward the tomb. The two were running together, but the other disciple outran Peter and reached the tomb first. He bent down to look in and saw the linen wrappings lying there, but he did not go in. Then Simon Peter came, following him, and went into the tomb. He saw the linen wrappings lying there, and the cloth that had been on Jesus’ head, not lying with the linen wrappings but rolled up in a place by itself. Then the other disciple, who reached the tomb first, also went in, and he saw and believed; for as yet they did not understand the scripture, that he must rise from the dead. Then the disciples returned to their homes.
But Mary stood weeping outside the tomb. As she wept, she bent over to look into the tomb; and she saw two angels in white, sitting where the body of Jesus had been lying, one at the head and the other at the feet. They said to her, “Woman, why are you weeping?” She said to them, “They have taken away my Lord, and I do not know where they have laid him.” When she had said this, she turned around and saw Jesus standing there, but she did not know that it was Jesus. Jesus said to her, “Woman, why are you weeping? Whom are you looking for?” Supposing him to be the gardener, she said to him, “Sir, if you have carried him away, tell me where you have laid him, and I will take him away.” Jesus said to her, “Mary!” She turned and said to him in Hebrew, “Rabbouni!” (which means Teacher). Jesus said to her, “Do not hold on to me, because I have not yet ascended to the Father. But go to my brothers and say to them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’” Mary Magdalene went and announced to the disciples, “I have seen the Lord”; and she told them that he had said these things to her.

The week after Easter, several years ago, I received an e-mail from someone who had attended the Easter service. He wrote, “Graham, I’ve been thinking about your Easter sermon. Do you really believe in the resurrection?” I wrote back, “Yep, I do. It would be hard for me to be a pastor and do what I do if I didn’t.”

He wrote back that he had always thought I was such an intelligent person, and that my belief surprised him. He then said that he would have a hard time attending the church of a pastor who actually believed in the resurrection. He had hoped that I would have been more enlightened. I guess the reason I feel comfortable telling this story is that he didn’t come back. But beyond that, he really exemplified one of the basic truths about Jesus Christ. The fact is that Jesus was and is the most transforming and controversial person ever born.

If you look at the impact of his life on the world, it is truly amazing. Because of his teachings, the world was transformed from an “eye for an eye” world to one that, over the centuries, has become more compassionate and caring. This transformation has been uneven and often has looked like two steps forward, one step back. But it’s undeniable that the world has been transformed. Look at our culture. We do things collectively now to help the poor, to reach out to victims of tragedies, to improve care of the sick, and to forgive enemies, that are the result of seeds planted by Christ in the gospels. Whether it is giving to charities, Welfare, the rebuilding of Germany and Japan after World War II, or helping to relieve AIDS in Africa, all have happened because of the influence of Jesus Christ. It’s the incarnation of his self-sacrificing love in the world.

Despite his impact on the world, what we know about his life and resurrection has led to so much doubt. Skeptics abound both about all aspects of Jesus’ life and resurrection. Whether you’re talking about the beliefs of Christians or non-Christians, there’s no real clarity on who Jesus was. Even among Christians there’s dispute. Many of us believe that Jesus was the incarnation of God on earth, and believe that he was resurrected. But there are also many who see themselves as Christian who believe that he was mainly a great prophet, and a great moral teacher. They can’t believe in his divinity or his resurrection. Still, they see themselves as Christians because they are committed to following his teachings. And I’m rarely critical of them because I recognize that they also produce good fruit in their lives by living out Jesus’ teachings. But what they demonstrate is that even among Christians Jesus is controversial and people have a hard time agreeing.

Muslims also have their views about Jesus. For example, most Christians don’t know that in the Muslim religion Jesus is considered to have been the second greatest prophet behind Mohammed. They revere Jesus, but not as the Son of God. They believe that Christians are deluded by their belief that God could be incarnate in a man, which they see as a blasphemy. Still, they believe that to be a good Muslim also means following the teachings of Jesus.

Many Buddhists also have their views about Jesus. They believe that Jesus was a buddha himself, which means that he was a bodhisattva, or enlightened being, who returned to lead others to enlightenment. Buddhists believe that some people eventually reach an enlightened state, and attaining that state choose to return to this life to lead others to enlightenment. Many Buddhists believe Jesus was an enlightened one.

Many agnostics believe that Jesus was simply a great man like Martin Luther King, Jr. or Mahatma Gandhi. They would say that if Jesus lived today, we’d recognize him as a great transformational figure, and nothing more.

There are also many atheists who would tell you that they’re not even sure Jesus existed. They would tell you that there is no historical record of Jesus outside of the Bible, which points to the fact that he was made up. It doesn’t matter that no one really wrote history back then, and the study of history is an Age of Enlightenment discipline that arose only when cultures became economically strong enough that certain people had the leisure to study and write history. In other words, there’s no historical record outside the Bible because people didn’t write history (actually, the Jewish writer, Josephus, did write about a person named Chrestou who caused trouble in Israel and was executed).

Just as there is controversy and confusion about Jesus’ life, there’s also just as much controversy and confusion about his resurrection. You have those who believe he was resurrected, and because of their beliefs they’ve actually had spiritual experiences that lead them to deepen their beliefs. Then there are those who say that Jesus was never resurrected, and that the apostles were simply lying. My struggle with that belief is that if you know the eventual fate of the apostles, all except John died terrible and painful deaths because of their beliefs. False prophets and liars rarely die for their beliefs, especially not willingly at the hands of others demanding that they give up their beliefs. Christianity is full of people dying for their beliefs.

A few years ago I had a conversation with a woman who really embodied the struggle with what to do with Jesus’s resurrection. She said that she was a Christian, and she loved to both read and tell stories about miracles that happen in people’s lives. But she told me that she didn’t believe in the resurrection because it didn’t make rational sense. I said to her, “Wait,… you believe in all these miracles that don’t make rational sense, but you don’t believe in the resurrection because it doesn’t make rational sense? You do recognize the contradiction, right?” She didn’t. She just kept insisting that the resurrection didn’t make rational sense.

Personally I’ve gone through every one of these views throughout my life. I’ve struggled with Jesus and with his resurrection. And I eventually came to the same conclusion as Soren Kierkegaard. Kierkegaard was a nineteenth century Danish philosopher who wrote a lot about what it means to be a Christian. Kierkegaard made an absolutely profound observation of the Christian life when he said that no person becomes a true Christian because it makes rational sense. He said that anyone who says that the Bible and Christian faith makes rational sense has never truly been a Christian. Instead, to be a Christian means to stand on the edge of an abyss of absurdity, with God on the other side. And at some point we need to leap across that abyss (what many now call “the leap of faith”) into God’s arms. We recognize that to do so seems like absurdity to the world at large, but we also know that until we do this we never really come to know God or live a real life lived with God. This leap is a leap of faith, not a rational choice.


What makes belief in Christ’s resurrection a leap is that it requires us to accept a truth about God and the universe. This truth is that God created everything according to certain laws of physics, and yet God gets to break these laws whenever God wants. God did not create a creation that is more powerful than God. God is beyond the created universe, and we understand, as Christians, that God often breaks into creation to do something that goes beyond the rules of creation. In other words, God both created and breaks the laws.

This ability of God to do things beyond the laws of nature is the reason why miracle stories are so prominent in both the Bible and in Christian history. If you look at both, you’ll find that for thousands of years people have been experiencing God in miraculous ways. Let me show you what I mean:

Do you know who Ben Carson is? For many years Ben Carson was the head of pediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins Medical Hospital. He did not start out on that path. Back when he was a kid living in the projects of Detroit, he expected little out of his life except to be dead from gun violence by the time he reached adulthood. He described himself as the dumbest kid in the fifth grade, but that all changed when a friend of his was shot. He and his family became determined that he would make something of himself. He eventually went to Yale, and then to Johns Hopkins for medical school. Today he is known worldwide for his work in separating a number of Siamese twins joined at the head.

Carson became world-renown at the end of 1997 when he and a team of specialists performed surgery in South Africa on a pair of Siamese twins from Zambia. The surgery lasted over thirty hours, and it was grueling. After nineteen hours of surgery, the surgery team took a break in the conference room, exhausted. Carson felt defeated. When they had cut through the skull and pulled the heads just a bit apart to see what the surgery required, Carson looked in and saw what he described as a mass of spaghetti. It was too complex. He had no way of knowing which vein or artery belonged where. He was overwhelmed and didn’t know what to do. The team considered stopping the operation, but they knew they couldn’t. Carson retreated to be by himself, and prayed. Carson prayed that God would take over and simply used him to accomplish what only God could do.

Carson went back into surgery. The heads were pulled back again, and again Carson looked in at the mass of spaghetti, but this time something different happened. Carson just knew what to do. It was as though God was in him, directing his hands and leading his thoughts. For the next six hours, he clipped this vein, attached that artery, cauterized this capillary, and reconnected that vein. At the very end of his part of the surgery, as he clipped the last vein connecting the twins, an amazing thing happened. The “Hallelujah Chorus” from Handel’s Messiah played over the stereo system. God had surprised Carson and the rest of the team by being a miraculous presence in their midst.

Jim Altman also discovered how God can work miracles in ways we don’t expect. Altman is the director of a school for emotionally disturbed children in Jacksonville, Florida. Several years ago he was in Columbus, Ohio to speak at a motivational conference. The morning of his talk he went to a local diner for breakfast. Sitting at the counter next to another man, both looked at their menus. The waitress asked Altman what he wanted. Altman pointed at the man next to him and said, “He was here first. Go ahead and take his order.” The man said to Altman, “No,… you go ahead. I’ve learned to be patient in my life.” So Altman gave his order, shortly followed by the other man.

As they sat on their stools, reading their papers, Altman leaned over and said, “So tell me how you learned to be patient.” The man introduced himself as Richard, and said, “I used to work in construction. About five years ago I fell off a rooftop and struck my head hard on the ground. I was taken to the hospital for emergency surgery, and had to go through almost a year of rehabilitation. I learned to be patient doing all my rehab. I also happened to be rushed to the perfect hospital for this kind of injury—Riverside Methodist Hospital. It turns out they have one of the best neurosurgery units in the country. Some would call it luck, but I’ve learned that we call it luck only when we’re too embarrassed to call it God. My friend, this is important. If you ever have a problem with your head, go to Riverside Methodist.” Jim thought to himself, “Yeah, that will do me a lot of good, living in Jacksonville.”

Later that afternoon, Jim took a run in Union Cemetery—a beautiful, old cemetery just off of the campus of Ohio State University. Suddenly a searing pain shot through his temple and through the base of his skull. It drove him to his knees. He could barely breathe because of the pain. He crawled as best he could to find help. Eventually, after twenty minutes, he crawled into the caretaker’s office. The caretaker asked him what to do, and Altman said, “Take me to Riverside Methodist Hospital,” which just happened to be across the street from the cemetery.

If Altman had not been so close to the hospital, or if he had gone somewhere else, he probably wouldn’t have survived. He had had a massive cranial hemorrhage. But the quick work of the hospital doctors and staff saved his life. Today, Altman knows what it is like to experience a miracle—one that’s not rational, but it is a miracle nonetheless.

Let me finish with just one more miraculous story. A number of years ago an atheist was hiking through a forest in Montana. It was stunningly beautiful. The atheist was in awe of the sky, the trees, the mountains, the streams—everything. Suddenly, out of the corner of his eye, he spotted something. A seven-foot grizzly appeared from behind a bush and rushed him. Now, we’re all told to freeze when rushed by a grizzly, but this man dropped everything and ran.

He ran fast, but the bear was faster. He cried out, “God, I know that I’ve never believed in you, but if you are there, please help me.” The bear rushed closer. Again, he prayed, “God, if you are there, please help me!” Suddenly everything froze—the bear, the birds flying by, the dust kicked up into the air. He heard a voice: “Sure, sure,… you pray to me now when you are in trouble. You disbelieve in me for most of your life, but now you want me to do something. You want me to save you.”

The atheist thought for a moment, and then said, “You’re right, God. Asking you to help me is quite hypocritical. And I don’t want to be a hypocrite. So how about this? Just make the bear a Christian?” God said, “Okay, it’s as you wish.”

Suddenly everything unfroze and the bear was running towards him again. But before the bear reached him, it stopped. It then dropped to its knees, folded its paws, and said in a human voice, “God is great, God is good, and we thank him for our food.”

I’ve discovered some basic truths about life that are important. First, you are what you eat. Second, you become who your friends are. Third, and this is the most important, you see what you believe. There’s so much in life that we can’t ever see until we start to believe it. But when we do believe, it’s amazing what we see. I learned this lesson several years ago right after we moved to our present home.

We live on an acre of wooded property, and one of the things I loved when we moved there was the beautiful green foliage covering the floor of the woods. A year after we moved there a person was visiting our house and asked me, “Graham, why do you let all that poison ivy grow everywhere.” I looked at him, puzzled: “What poison ivy?” “It’s everywhere,” he said, “All in those woods.” That was the beautiful green foliage covering the floor of the woods. I don’t get poison ivy, so I never saw it as poison ivy. Once I knew what it was, I saw it everywhere.

Faith is the same way. If you don’t believe, you can’t see. But once you believe, it’s amazing what you see.

We’re gathered today to celebrate a miracle that many people did witness, and it’s a miracle that has made a difference in billions of lives. But to discover he power of that miracle, believing is seeing.

Amen.

Questions for God: Do Angels Exist?

By Connie Frierson



After slugging through some tough questions for God, I nabbed the one and only question lite. “Do Angels Really Exist?” I figured for Palm Sunday after weeks of dealing with Terrorism, Tragedy, Doubts and Struggles, it would be a good thing to turn our attention to something sublime. So the question is do angels exist. Let’s start by turning that question around. Do you believe angels exist?
Let’s look at the general, ordinary population says about angels. Not that you all are representative of all America, think you all are remarkable and not at all ordinary. But if you were the folks who answered the Time Magazine poll, the polling would go something like this. About 69% of you believe angels exist. So all of you on the main sections stand up. This would be the people who believe in angels. This section, over there in the Friendship Room, are the skeptics. Of this 69% about 46% believe in personal guardian angels, Actually a Baylor University pole showed that 55% believe in guardian angels. So people in these two sections remain standing. Of this group, 32% have had some encounter or experience of an angelic presence. Look at all those people. Suppose that they were not all clumped together but spread out among you. That would mean that sitting right next to you or two people down the row is someone who has encountered an angelic presence.
But if your neighbor has met an angel they probably aren’t talking about it. Nancy Gibbs wrote an article in Time Magazine. She writes. “Maybe it is not surprising that people who believe they have had an encounter with angels are among the most reluctant to discuss them. Yet there is an uncanny similarity in the stories and a moving conviction behind them. Very often the recognition comes only in retrospect. A person is in immediate danger -- the car stalled in the deadly snowstorm, the small plane lost in the fog, the swimmer too far from shore. And emerging from the moment's desperation comes some logical form of rescue: a tow-truck driver, a voice from the radio tower, a lifeguard. But when the victim is safe and turns to give thanks, the rescuer is gone. There are no tire tracks in the snow. There is no controller in the tower. And there are no footprints on the beach.”
This experience of the mysterious presence of another, who comfort, guides and brings peace and hope, is so common in human experience that an author, John Geiger has written a book that collects hundred’s of stories of these figures. This is a secular book so he does not call them angels. The book is called, The Third Man Factor. Have any of you heard of the third man factor? If you haven’t heard of this phenomenon it is probably because you do not hang around with mountaineers or extreme climbers. But in that community the sense of another presence hiking with you when you are in danger is so strong and so common that mountaineers have coined this term, the third man factor.
The stories are populated with extraordinary people, rational people, explorers, sailors, mountain climbers, aviators, deep-sea divers and scientists. Many of the people who have had these experiences have mountains or rare species of plants and animals named after them. One of the most famous and typical of the stories is of Sir Ernst Shackleton. In 1914 Shackleton led an expedition to explore the Antarctic. The ship became ice bound and was crushed. The crew made it off the boat and became stranded on Elephant Island. In desperation Shackleton, and five others, took off to make a 680-mile voyage to South Georgia to seek rescue. By a complete miracle they made the voyage but then realized they were on the wrong side of the island and needed to cover a mountain range and glacier to reach the South Georgia whaling station. Shackleton, and two others, Frank Worsley and Tom Crean, walked and climbed and slid over the mountain range. As they walked more dead than alive, each of these three men experienced a fourth man in their company. This presence encouraged them, steadied them, and led them. Each of the three had independently experienced this presence. The stories of those who sense the miraculous and mysterious presence of another are so similar. Often they involve a physical struggle that is life threatening, profound loneliness, loss and being pushed to the limit. Scientist struggle to explain this sense of presence. Some have surmised that these stories are some kind of hallucination brought about by some breakdown of brain function. But hallucinations are maladaptive. These visions lead not to mistakes but to amazing triumphs and endurance. Some have thought that they involve lost of oxygen or high altitudes and result from some organic chemical changes. But these stories transcend altitude. Some occur at sea level or in caves. Many sense this presence without any altitude or oxygen challenge. Shackleton put it this way, in these moments they have, “pierced the veneer of outside things.”
These experiences aren’t limited to mountaintops. Nancy Gibbs article in Time Magazine recounts the experience of Melissa Deal a filmmaker in Atlanta. “Melissa will never forget the day her husband Chris Deal died: it was exactly one year after he had been diagnosed with acute lymphocytic leukemia. The last months had been gruesome: treatments that could not save him, nights when she could not sleep. But she was sleeping soundly at his hospital bedside on the morning of Jan. 4 when Chris managed, somehow, without being seen or heard, to maneuver himself and his portable IV pole around her, out of the room and past the nurse's station with its 360 degrees view of the ward. All Melissa remembers is being shaken awake at 3 a.m. by a frantic nurse who was saying something about not being able to find Chris. Melissa hit the floor running. As she approached the elevator she happened to glance toward the chapel, where she glimpsed Chris sitting with a man she had never seen before. Frightened and furious, she burst through the door, firing off questions. "Where have you been? Are you okay?" Chris just smiled. "It's fine," he told her, "I'm all right." His companion remained quiet, his eyes on the floor as though not wanting to be noticed. He was tall, dressed rather like Chris usually did, in a flannel shirt, new Levis and lace-up work boots that appeared as if they, too, had just been taken off the shelf. "There was no real age to him," Melissa says. "No wrinkles. Just this perfectly smooth and pale, white, white skin and ice blue eyes. I mean I've never seen that color blue on any human before. They were more the blue like some of those Husky dogs have. I'll never forget the eyes."
Chris seemed to want to be left alone, and so she reluctantly agreed to leave. When he came back to his room, she says, "He was lit up, just vibrant. Smiling. I could see his big dimples. I hadn't seen them in so long. He didn't have the air of a terminally ill and very weak man anymore."
"Who was that guy?" she asked.
"You're not going to believe me."
"Yes, I will."
"He was an angel. My guardian angel."
Melissa did believe him. "All I had to do was to look at him to know something extraordinary, something supernatural had happened."
She searched the hospital to find the man. There was no one around, and the security guards hadn't seen anyone come or go. "After the visit, Chris told me his prayers had been answered. I worried for a while that he thought the angel had cured his cancer. I realize now it wasn't the cure, it was the blessing he brought with him. It was the peace of mind." Chris died two days later.
In the 11 years since Chris's death, Melissa says not a day has gone by when she has not thought about the angel and what he did for her husband. "Chris' life could not be saved, but the fear and pain were taken from him,"
If there is such a thing as a universal idea, common across cultures and through the centuries, the belief in angels comes close to it. Jews, Christians and Muslims have postulated endlessly about angels' nature and roles, but all three religions affirm their existence. There are angels in Buddhism, Hinduism and Zoroastrianism; winged figures appear in ancient Sumerian carvings, Egyptian tombs and Assyrian reliefs.
Visible or invisible, in disguise or in full glory, angels appear in more than half the books of the Bible: it was an angel who told Abraham to spare his son from sacrifice, who saved Daniel from the lion's den, who rolled the stone away from Christ's tomb. It was a host of angels who appeared to the shepherds and the angel Gabriel spoke to Mary. It was an angel who led Peter out of jail, encouraged Paul when he was about to be shipwrecked. It was angels who fed and nurtured Elijah and Jesus in the wilderness. Jacob wrestles with an angel at Bethel and has a dream of a ladder going up and down from heaven to earth with angels ascending and descending. The bible is full of angelic presence.
Perhaps the more important question is not “Do angels exist?” but rather “What difference does it make that angels exist?” Jacob’s ladder is a vision of the spiritual realm. Angel’s presence on the earth and in heaven tells us that while we live in a material world, our world is primarily and completely a spiritual world. God is reaching out in infinite ways to humanity. It is telling that the most angel rich area of the bible is Christmas and Easter. Angels proclaim and witness to the incarnation and the resurrection. There when God is coming into the world in the flesh, angels are there in hosts. When Christ vanquishes death and brings the Kingdom of heaven closer to earth, angels are there to witness to the resurrection. This shouldn’t surprise us. The very language of the bible points to the core aspect of angels. In Hebrew the word for angel is malak. In Greek the word for angel is anggelos. Both mean messenger. Angels worship God. Angels do the will of God. Angels protect and comfort and assist, because that is the will of our God. Angels are evidence of God’s love for us.
It is time to share one of my angel stories, a story without fire works or obvious supernatural elements but an angel story nonetheless. I need to show you my favorite of all the gifts I received for my graduation from seminary. This is an angel I received from Rose, my kids bus driver. You have to understand Rose to get the hilarity of this gift. This sweet little angel is from the toughest bus driver ever to get behind the wheel in the tri-state area. Rose is a law and order bus driver, hard as nails. Kids don’t get away with spit with Rose at the wheel. Rose is a character. She drives a black and white spotted Holstein painted bus in demolition school bus races. I think Rose got this angel at a truck stop on the way home from the school bus racing circuit. I was so touched that she wanted to give me something. But the shear kitsch of this gift just triggered all my anti-angel bias. This curvy angelic chick is like a Disney princess with fiber optic wings. She isn’t powerful like Michael, or frightening like Gabriel or mysterious like the visitors to Abraham or the presence of the fourth man in the fire furnace. But this is what this angel did for us. My graduation was a bittersweet time. I was celebrating an accomplishment but it was so sad not to have my dad, or my mom, or my husband there to share it with me. My whole extended family was there to help with the party the whole weekend but we all felt the loss. It brought our mourning out afresh. Yet throughout the weekend, we would set this little angel glowing and we would break out into laughter, laughter all out of proportion to the joke. I think we ran the batteries out. So who was the angel here, a little plastic and feather nick knack, or Rose, who kept my kids safe and was so kind, or this congregation that celebrated with me or is this all evidence of a God who loves me, knows me inside and out and who gave me the gift of laughter in the midst of sadness.
We are not alone. It matters that our world is filled with a community of beings who love us, encourage us and guide us. It matters that we have people like Rose, people like this congregation. It matters that Christ’s love extends to us through his spirit and through angels. We live in a rich spiritual world of God’s creation.


Amen.

Questions for God: What Does Jesus Mean by "Turn the Other Cheek?"

Matthew 5:38-42
April 10, 2011



You have heard that it was said, “An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.” But I say to you, Do not resist an evildoer. But if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn the other also; and if anyone wants to sue you and take your coat, give your cloak as well; and if anyone forces you to go one mile, go also the second mile. Give to everyone who begs from you, and do not refuse anyone who wants to borrow from you.

You know, there’s a fundamental problem with both Christianity and Christ’s teachings. And it’s a problem that most non-Christians easily recognize, and that most Christians grapple with. What’s the problem? It’s that Christ’s teachings, and therefore Christianity’s teachings, go so much against basic human nature that we have a really, really hard time living them out. Throughout the Bible there are just too many teachings that conflict with the ways we naturally think. And our passage for today is one of those teachings. How could Jesus have taught “turning the other cheek” in the face of the realities and practicalities of the world?

The fact is that we don’t live in a “turn the other cheek” world, nor has anyone ever lived in one. For Jesus to expect us to act like this when it would make us sacrificial lambs is unfair and unrealistic. The Jewish and Muslim faiths seem to be much more in tune with our basic human nature because they teach “an eye for an eye.” It’s not just they who live according to that nature. The realities of international affairs agree with this idea. If you attack my country, I’ll attack yours. If you shoot at me, I’ll shoot at you. This is the reality of human life. This is how humans were created to think. In fact, thousands of years ago when “an eye for an eye” was coined, it was an enlightened view. You don’t take both eyes for your loss of one eye. You respond in a measured, equal way.

Everything I’ve just said is absolutely true. Jesus’ teachings completely go against our basic human nature, and seem unrealistic in the face of the world’s realities, but so what? Living out of our basic human nature is important only if our goal in life is to live a basic human life. If our goal is simply to live as people normally live, and not live an exceptional life, this line of thinking is right on target. The problem is that both Christianity and Christ want us to live exceptional lives, and “turning the other cheek” is central to living an exceptional life.

What does it mean to live this kind of exceptional life? Let me show you. Back in 1960, Dr. Robert Coles, who has spent a career at Harvard as a psychiatrist, was a psychiatrist working for the U. S. Air Force at Keesler Air Force Base in Biloxi, Mississippi. It was six years after the landmark Supreme Court decision of Brown vs. the Board of Education, which ordered the desegregation of all schools. In 1960 a federal court in Louisiana ordered that the schools of the New Orleans area had to immediately desegregate. Protests erupted. Being a psychiatrist with an interest in social issues, Coles decided to drive down to the William T. Franz School in New Orleans to see what was taking place.

He arrived thirty minutes before school ended to see an angry crowd gathering. He asked some people what was happening, and they responded, “She’s coming out in half an hour.” “Who’s she?” he asked. They responded by cursing and shouting about this evil girl who had disrupted their quiet lives.

Then came the anticipated moment. The crowd erupted in fury as a little, seven-year-old African-American girl named Ruby Bridges came out of the school, surrounded by federal marshals. The crowd erupted, cursing her, shaking their fists and baseball bats, and threatening her with violence. Through it all Ruby walked calmly between the federal marshals.

Coles decided that this would be a good opportunity for him to do some good while also studying a unique situation. He went to visit with Ruby and her family. They lived in a shack in a poor neighborhood. Coles came to his first visit, armed with all the latest psychiatric techniques. Sitting down at the kitchen table with her he asked, “How are you doing, Ruby?” “I’m okay,” she replied. He looked at her mother, “Mrs. Bridges, how is Ruby doing?” “Doctor, she’s doing fine.” “Is Ruby sleeping okay?” “Oh yes, Ruby’s sleeping fine.” “How’s Ruby’s appetite?” “It’s fine.” “Are you sure she’s eating well?” “Yes, doctor.” “How do you think Ruby’s doing with her friends when she comes home from School?” “Ruby’s fine when she comes home. She plays and sometimes reads from the books they give her at school. She’s just in the first grade, learning how to read, you know.” “Yes, I know. But doesn’t she seem upset at times?” “No doctor, Ruby doesn’t seem upset.”

Mrs. Bridges’ responses baffled Coles. According to all of his training, Ruby should be exhibiting some sort of adjustment reaction to her situation. Perhaps it was due to Mrs. Bridges ignorance in not knowing what to look for because of her lack of education.

Coles kept tabs on Ruby for the next few months. Nothing much changed in their responses to him. Were they in denial, or just repressing? He wondered. One day he interviewed Ruby’s teacher, who said, “You know, I don’t understand this child. She seems so happy. She comes here so cheerfully.” Coles asked her if she ever saw anything out of the ordinary in Ruby’s reaction to the situation surrounding her. The teacher told him that the only thing she noticed was that Ruby often paused, close her eyes, and spoke to the crowd as she walked by. This was the tidbit Coles had been looking for. Obviously Ruby was cursing the crowd back. That was how she was dealing with the stress of the situation.

Coles sat down with Ruby and her family again to zero in on this symptom: “I was talking to your teacher today, and she told me that she saw you talking to the people on the street.” “Oh yes,” Ruby said, “I told her that I wasn’t talking to them. I was just saying a prayer for them.” Coles responded, “Ruby, do you pray for those people on the street?” “Yes,” she said. “Why do you do that?” “Because they need praying for.” “Do they?” “Oh yes.”

Coles then talked to Ruby’s mother about it, and she said, “We tell Ruby that it’s important to pray for those people.” She then said that they had the people on a list and prayed for them every night. Ruby had learned to pray for them in Sunday School. Coles responded, “You know, it strikes me that ‘s a lot to ask of Ruby. I mean, given what she’s been going through.” Mrs. Bridges looked at Coles and said, “She does it herself, even when we don’t want to pray for them ourselves. Don’t you think they need praying for?”

Coles didn’t know what to say. Prayer had not been discussed in any of his psychiatric training. He turned to Ruby and said, “Ruby, when you pray for those people on the street, what do you say?” She replied, “My minister told me that Jesus went through a lot of trouble too, and when people shouted at him and said bad things to him, when Jesus was on the cross, he prayed for those people. So I pray for them too.” “Ruby, what do you say when you pray?” “I say, ‘Father forgive them, because they don’t know what they are doing?”

Ruby, a seven year-old girl, understood turning the other cheek. It means neither responding with violence, nor backing down. In many ways, Ruby was living out what was being taught at the time by Martin Luther King, Jr., which is that the world can be transformed by turning the other cheek. King, who based the Civil Rights protests both on the Sermon on the Mount, and the experiences and teachings of Mahatma Gandhi (who, himself, was trying to apply the teachings of the Sermon on the Mount).

King believed and taught that when we face our enemies and turn the other cheek, we hold a mirror up to them so that they can see the injustice and evil of their acts. King made a very clear distinction about the bigots of his day who wanted to maintain segregation. He believed that the practice of segregation was evil, and that the people defending it, as well as those shouting epithets at little girls like Ruby, were doing evil but were not evil. He saw these people as churchgoing folk who wanted to do right, who were trying to do God’s will, but who couldn’t distinguish good from evil. He wanted to transform them from enemy to friend, from evil acts to good acts. He knew that the key to this transformation was to change our behavior first. He called the Christians of the Civil Rights Movement to be transformed from basic human reactions in the face of evil to exceptional reactions. In essence, he was saying that by massively turning the other cheek in the face of bigotry, the bigots and the nation could be transformed, but the first step was transforming the protestors. They would turn the other cheek.

The difficulty for us is that we aren’t in the Civil Rights Movement, but that doesn’t meant that turning the other cheek has no role in our lives. For us the question is how we “turn the other cheek” in practical places, such as the workplace and elsewhere, where fighting for yourself and getting respect from others is really important. I think the basic problem is that people don’t really understand what turning the other cheek means. It doesn’t mean being weak. It means being stronger than those who are afraid of losing power. When we turn the other cheek, we are standing our ground. We are saying to others, definitively, “I will not run away from you, nor will I hurt you, but I will also not let you dominate me. I am going to be your equal. If you decide to hurt me, I’ll take your hurt, but I will not treat you the way you are treating me. And in the end I hope that we will find a way to work together—that we will become friends, colleagues, and companions.”

In the workplace it means that I will neither let you treat me disrespectfully, nor will I treat you disrespectfully. If you criticize or hurt me, I will not run away, nor will I hurt you back. I will stand before you and with you until you are willing to treat me in a way that allows us to work for what’s best. These same principles apply in every other relationship—friendships, marriages, parenting, and more. Turning the other cheek creates healthy relationships.

I learned about this aspect of turning the other cheek back in sixth grade. I remember that one of the other kids, Bruce McWilliams, got very angry at me for some reason, and wanted to fight. Being a bit of a strange kid at the time, I had chosen Martin Luther King, Jr., as my role model. He had been shot three years earlier, and I was captivated by what he did, as well as by what Mahatma Gandhi did in India. Most kids chose athletes or astronauts as their heroes. Mine were “turn-the-other-cheekers.” So trying to channel my inner MLK, Jr., I stood before Bruce and told him I wasn’t going to fight. He tried to hit me, and I grabbed his arms as he fell on top of me. I kept telling him that I wasn’t going to fight, but I wasn’t afraid. He just got more and more frustrated. But eventually he got off of me, and I saw then and there that my response puzzled him. I think that my not fighting with him actually allowed us to become friends.

Turning the other cheek doesn’t just mean standing our ground. It also means bringing about cooperation between others and us. When I think of this aspect of turning the other cheek, I think of Nelson Mandela. Here was a man who was imprisoned in hard labor for over 25 years by the Apartheid regime in South Africa, but when he was set free and then eventually became president, he turned the other cheek in a way that allowed the country to come together. With a black population that outnumbered the white population almost 17:1, he very easily could have promoted revenge. Yet when he became president he refused to act in any way other than graciously, showing through speech and behavior that he was willing to diminish his will in order to promote unity and cooperation in the nation. For a great example of this, see the film, Invictus. It wonderfully shows how turning the other cheek on a grand scale can unite people.

Finally, turning the other cheek forms and restores relationships. When we are willing to turn our cheek in the face of anger, it overcomes division and promotes connection. I had an experience of this last summer. I was driving down a road near our house, and as is sometimes the case, I was driving way too fast. As I rounded a curve, I passed a group of people standing outside while working on a house. One of the men, furious at my speed, came running towards my car, threw something at it, and yelled at me. My natural inclination was to do one of two things: to stop and yell back while thrusting the appropriate finger in the air, or to just keep driving with my finger out the window. I normally don’t do these things, but I always feel like doing them. Instead, I stopped and slowly backed up, winding down my window. I immediately said to him, “I know I was driving too fast. I’m really sorry.” His face changed from purple to normal, and he said, “No, I’m sorry. I’ve seen so many people driving so fast around that curve, and I lost my temper.” I said, “No, you’ve had every right to do that. I was going way too fast, and I know I have to slow down on this road, so you’re helping me.” We both kept doing our best Chip and Dale act, insisting that it was me, not the other, who was at fault. In then I apologized one more time and drove away. We’re able to wave and say hi now each time I pass. And it’s due to both of us turning our cheeks to each other.

When I think about turning the other cheek, I don’t only think about it in terms of protest. I think of it in terms of how we manage our lives. Turning the other cheek basically says that I am going to live a life that’s focused on love, respect, cooperation, and letting the Christ in me meet the Christ in you. I won’t back down, I won’t strike back, but I will look for a way to meet you in the middle. I just wish that this was something our politicians could learn.

Amen.

Questions for God: Why Does God Let Good People Suffer?



2 Corinthians 12:1-10
April 3, 2011

It is necessary to boast; nothing is to be gained by it, but I will go on to visions and revelations of the Lord. I know a person in Christ who fourteen years ago was caught up to the third heaven—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know; God knows. And I know that such a person—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know; God knows— was caught up into Paradise and heard things that are not to be told, that no mortal is permitted to repeat. On behalf of such a one I will boast, but on my own behalf I will not boast, except of my weaknesses. But if I wish to boast, I will not be a fool, for I will be speaking the truth. But I refrain from it, so that no one may think better of me than what is seen in me or heard from me, even considering the exceptional character of the revelations. Therefore, to keep me from being too elated, a thorn was given me in the flesh, a messenger of Satan to torment me, to keep me from being too elated. Three times I appealed to the Lord about this, that it would leave me, but he said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness.” So, I will boast all the more gladly of my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ may dwell in me. Therefore I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and calamities for the sake of Christ; for whenever I am weak, then I am strong.

Back in 1991, when I was an associate pastor, I received a visit one day from a troubled young man. I had been working in my office, and the secretary stepped in and said, “There’s a young man here who wants to see you. He looks really troubled and upset.” I told her to send him in. Before I could even introduce myself he said, “Why does God let good people suffer and die?” That’s not an easy question to answer even with a lot of thought, but it’s especially difficult to answer right out of the blue. I took a step back with him, asked him his name, told him mine, and then I asked, “What’s happened to you that’s causing you to wonder? It’s obvious that something bad has happened.” He said, “I don’t understand why Senator John Heinz died yesterday in a helicopter accident. He was a really good man. Why did he have to die?”

He told me that he had been a college intern in Heinz’s senate office, and that Heinz was one of his heroes. We talked for about an hour, and then he left. I don’t think that anything I said helped. I’m not sure that there was anything that I could have said that would have helped. The problem was that he really didn’t want “God” answers. He didn’t want to hear anything about the promise of Heaven, he didn’t want to hear anything about how God created the universe, and he didn’t want to hear about trusting in God. I’m not sure what kind of answer he wanted, but it was clear that nothing I could say was going to make a difference. He had questions, but he also placed restrictions on the kinds of answers I could give.

I learned early on in my ministry that it’s very difficult to answer people when they ask why God lets good people suffer and/or die because they set the parameters of the answer. Often the people asking only want answers that fit with their already-formed theologies about the way the world either does or should work. In other words, people may ask us why God lets good people suffer, but that does not mean that they are interested in our answers, especially if the answers don’t fit their already held beliefs.

So, why does God let good people suffer? I have to answer the question from within Christian parameters—from a Christian perspective. To answer the question, we have start with a basic fallacy that so many people have, which is that a good God would only let good things happen. The Bible really shows both that God is good, and that bad things happen. Looking at our primary source, the Bible, it’s clear that a good God not only lets bad things happen, but the Bible wants to teach us how to live with suffering.

Our passage for today is a great example of that. The apostle Paul, whom we can lift up as an example of the great Christian life, has this incredible experience in which he is lifted up to the third heaven (whatever that is). He goes on to say that even though he has had this experience, he still has something that causes a great deal of suffering for him. In other words, God may have given him a glimpse of Heaven, but that doesn’t take away his suffering. He calls his affliction a “thorn in the flesh.”

We don’t quite know what that thorn was. It might have been some sort of physical impediment he’s had his whole life. It might be physical damage caused by the several beatings he had received at the hands of people who saw him as a danger. It might be something else. Whatever it was, Paul prayed three times for God to heal him, and he hears something surprising. God says to him, “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness.” Paul then testifies, “So, I will boast all the more gladly of my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ may dwell in me. Therefore I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and calamities for the sake of Christ; for whenever I am weak, then I am strong.

Paul is saying that a good God doesn’t take away suffering. A good God, instead, uses our suffering to bring grace into our lives.

Let’s look again at the question: So, why does God let good people suffer? To answer the question we also have to look at the whole nature of Creation. If we look at the nature of Creation, we discover that suffering happens because of God’s goodness. That’s an odd statement, isn’t it? But it’s true. To understand what I mean, we have to recognize the dual nature of all of Creation, which means that everything has the potential for good and bad. God creates everything as good, but even all this good can lead to what is bad and causes suffering. You can’t have good without the potential for the bad.

For instance, look at nuclear fission—the nuclear reaction in which the splitting of an atom causes the release of great quantities of energy. Nuclear fission can lead to great good. As I write this, the electric power giving me light, allowing me to use a computer, a printer, the ability to post it on a website, and more all come from a nearby nuclear power plant. But that same fission can create bombs that have the power to destroy the whole planet.

Food has a dual nature. It keeps us alive, and it can lead to great pleasure. We’ve all had meals that were incredibly delicious. But too much food can lead to obesity that leads to chronic illness and premature death.

Music has a dual nature. It can inspire us to experience God’s presence, and lift us to live better lives. It can soothe us, too, when we are stressed. Yet it can be a destructive force, too. Look at how Communist and fascist countries use music to brainwash whole populations into obedience. Music can also be personally destructive. When I worked as a counselor with teens in a psychiatric hospital, we saw how destructive the music could be. Many of the kids who were angry and suicidal were listening to groups like AC/DC, Black Sabbath, and Ozzy Osbourne, and some talked about that music’s influence in their self-destructiveness.

Gardens have a dual nature. That beauty that you cultivate in your garden also kills and causes suffering to weeds and insects.

Earth tectonics—the movement plate of tectonic plates across the top layer of the earth—allows for life to exist on earth. The fact that the earth’s crust is flexible caused massive eruptions millions of years ago (billions?) that allowed oxygen to form in our atmosphere, and soil to accumulate on the surface. Tectonic plate movement has given us life, but it also leads to earthquakes that cause massively destructive tsunamis like the one two weeks ago in Japan. Tectonics give us life, but also takes it away.

Even pain has a dual nature. That physical or psychological pain that leads to suffering, and that we want to avoid, actually keeps us alive. You and I hate pain, but without it we would die quickly. For example, have you heard of Hansen’s disease (what we often call “leprosy”)? It’s a disease that is said to cause people to lose their extremities—fingers, toes, noses, ears, etc… In fact, it’s not the disease that causes the loss of the extremities. The disease simply kills nerve endings so that people can’t feel pain at all. And their inability to feel pain means that they bump fingers and toes, but don’t realize it. Their lack of feeling allows infections to grow in these bumped fingers and toes, but, again, they don’t realize it. Eventually the extremities become gangrenous, and need to be cut off. It’s the loss of pain that leads to the loss of fingers and limbs. Pain keeps us alive by helping us to avoid things that could hurt, maim, or kill us.

Everything has a dual nature, and that nature can bring great pleasure and joy, or pain and suffering. If God were to get rid of the suffering, God would also have to get rid of pleasure and joy. God would have to get rid of the good in order to get rid of the bad.

So, why does God let good people suffer? If you want to understand suffering, it also starts with recognizing that there are two sources of suffering, and much of our suffering comes from the latter, not the former. The first kind of suffering is the nature of nature. In other words, nature leads to illness and death. Nature leads to earthquakes, tsunamis, tornadoes, hurricanes, and more. Nature, by being nature, can lead to suffering.

But by far the biggest cause of human suffering is the second source, which is human acts—what we inflict on each other. We humans do terrible things to each other either out of direct desire to harm others, or out of our own ignorance on how our actions hurt others. We criticize each other, neglect each other, abuse each other, commit acts of violence upon others, and fight wars with each other. Most of our acts come from selfishness, pride, and a lack of concern for others. Even much of what we see as good can cause suffering. For instance, just seeking a profit in business can lead to decisions that harm others economically and socially. In other words, most of the time suffering has nothing to do with anything God has done, but arises out of the freedom God gives us to do what we do. Human life causes suffering.

So, why does God let good people suffer? Much of it is directly due to the freedom God gives us and all of Creation. God’s given both the universe and us freedom to act in ways that bring life, beauty, destruction, and pain—all together.

So, why does God let good people suffer? Another answer is that it goes with the nature of redemption and transformation. In many cases suffering is the first step in redemption and transformation. Think about your own life. How often have you grown after a bad experience? How often has it been the failure that eventually led to success? What would Christianity look like without the cross? The Bible constantly pushes how experiences of suffering can lead us to a greater awareness of God. Think of your own life. If you are like most people, it’s periods of struggle that have led you to reach out for God.

In fact, it’s the lack of struggle among teens and young adults that often leads to an ignorance of God or the need for church and faith. For most teens and young adults, they live in safety pods either at home or at college. They have their food, shelter, entertainment, and more all taken care of. Suffering is kept to a minimum. And so their need for God is also diminished. Suffering has the ability to lead us to look for God, and to find God.

So, why does God let good people suffer? I think that the question really isn’t why God let’s good people suffer? I think for us Christians it’s a question of how we respond to suffering:
• How will we respond to the suffering of tsunami victims?
• How will we care for the grieving?
• How will we care for those who are sick and in pain?
• How will we care for the hungry, the poor, the homeless?
• How will we tend to the world’s pain?

Amen.